I’ve noticed something in the responses all you lunatics in the Anime Vice community have been leaving in my reviews of these Eva episodes, so far. Some of you are you saying that Shinji is an idiot, while others are chiming in that, in so many words, Eva is so good partly because he’s an idiot. That is, it’s a lot more accurate that a 14-year-old mecha pilot would have a lot undesirable qualities and he’d be doing a lot of things wrong. Seeing that in play in this episode reminds me of ruminations I’ve had about characterization in genre stories myself. See (and I know this is going to stir up a lot of wrath here) I’m a fan of the Star Wars prequels. More so than the classic trilogy, actually. Part of my reasons for liking the series can actually be phrased in the same terms a lot of detractors use to express why they don’t like the series. Specifically for ATTACK OF THE CLONES, people say that Anakin is whiney, that he’s a moron who makes a lot of stupid decisions and that he’s a serious creep when it comes to his relationship to Padme. In my mind, a character would be like that in those situations and, more importantly, it was far more interesting to see a maladjusted stalker being the “Chosen One” than a generic leading man or an equally generic reluctant hero. Tying that all back to Eva… this is a character episode (and I dug it for that) so there’s not as much to comment on, story wise. There is a lot to comment on, however, regarding character. While the premise of a 14-year-old being selected to pilot a weapon of mass destruction is a might unbelievable, his characterization here isn't. I think audiences a lot of times ask too much of protagonists. They want them to make the right decisions all the time, when, not only is that less “real”, it’s also less interesting. Sure, maybe it’s not the smartest thing to quit from Nerv like he did, and it's even more spineless to subsequently waver on his decision -- but it’s believable. This is a kid, here. He’s got very little figured out and his missteps aren’t going to be cute or charming. They’re going to be awkward… and more interesting than the typical “gallant pilot” you’d meet in a regular sentai show. -- Tom Pinchuk is the writer of UNIMAGINABLE for Arcana Comics and HYBRID BASTARDS! for Archaia. Pre-order the HYBRID BASTARDS! hardcover now on Amazon.com.
Read the rest of this entry
Entry meta